Effects of Spiralling Trajectories on White Dwarf Spectra: Remarks on Different Calculations

The purpose of this paper is to address conflicting results regarding a simple criterion that has been proposed as decisive in determining whether accounting for spiralling electron trajectories increases or decreases the widths of hydrogen lines in a parameter range relevant to the spectral lines of white dwarfs. We analyse the claims in detail and also provide explicit calculations. It is shown that the recent attempts to justify a simple theory are erroneous and miss important physics.