DOI: 10.1111/jsr.13956 ISSN: 0962-1105

Multicentre sleep‐stage scoring agreement in the Sleep Revolution project

Sami Nikkonen, Pranavan Somaskandhan, Henri Korkalainen, Samu Kainulainen, Philip I. Terrill, Heidur Gretarsdottir, Sigridur Sigurdardottir, Kristin Anna Olafsdottir, Anna Sigridur Islind, María Óskarsdóttir, Erna Sif Arnardóttir, Timo Leppänen
  • Behavioral Neuroscience
  • Cognitive Neuroscience
  • General Medicine

Summary

Determining sleep stages accurately is an important part of the diagnostic process for numerous sleep disorders. However, as the sleep stage scoring is done manually following visual scoring rules there can be considerable variation in the sleep staging between different scorers. Thus, this study aimed to comprehensively evaluate the inter‐rater agreement in sleep staging. A total of 50 polysomnography recordings were manually scored by 10 independent scorers from seven different sleep centres. We used the 10 scorings to calculate a majority score by taking the sleep stage that was the most scored stage for each epoch. The overall agreement for sleep staging was κ = 0.71 and the mean agreement with the majority score was 0.86. The scorers were in perfect agreement in 48% of all scored epochs. The agreement was highest in rapid eye movement sleep (κ = 0.86) and lowest in N1 sleep (κ = 0.41). The agreement with the majority scoring varied between the scorers from 81% to 91%, with large variations between the scorers in sleep stage‐specific agreements. Scorers from the same sleep centres had the highest pairwise agreements at κ = 0.79, κ = 0.85, and κ = 0.78, while the lowest pairwise agreement between the scorers was κ = 0.58. We also found a moderate negative correlation between sleep staging agreement and the apnea–hypopnea index, as well as the rate of sleep stage transitions. In conclusion, although the overall agreement was high, several areas of low agreement were also found, mainly between non‐rapid eye movement stages.

More from our Archive