Use of induction therapy post‐heart transplantation: Clinical practice recommendations based on systematic review and network meta‐analysis of evidence
Farid Foroutan, Gordon Guyatt, Josef Stehlik, Finn Gustafsson, Douglas Greig, Michael McDonald, Alejandro Mario Bertolotti, Lakshmi Kugathasan, Daniel G. Rayner, Carlos A. Cuello, Amanda Cook, Darko Zlatanoski, Sujivan Ram, Penny Demas‐Clarke, Stella Kozuszko, Ana Carolina Alba- Transplantation
Abstract
Background
The use of induction therapy (IT) agents in the early post‐heart transplant period remains controversial. The following recommendations aim to provide guidance on the use of IT agents, including Basiliximab and Thymoglobulin, as part of routine care in heart transplantation (HTx).
Methods
We recruited an international, multidisciplinary panel of 15 stakeholders, including patient partners, transplant cardiologists and surgeons, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, and methodologists. We commissioned a systematic review on benefits and harms of IT on patient‐important outcomes, and another on patients’ values and preferences to inform our recommendations. We used the GRADE framework to summarize our findings, rate certainty in the evidence, and develop recommendations. The panel considered the balance between benefits and harms, certainty in the evidence, and patient's values and preferences, to make recommendations for or against the routine post‐operative use of Thymoglobulin or Basiliximab.
Results
The panel made recommendations on three major clinical problems in HTx: (1) We suggest against the routine post‐operative use of Basiliximab compared to no IT, (2) we suggest against the routine use of Thymoglobulin compared to no IT, and (3) for those patients for whom IT is deemed desirable, we suggest for the use of Thymoglobulin as compared to Basiliximab.
Conclusion
This report highlights gaps in current knowledge and provides directions for clinical research in the future to better understand the clinical utility of IT agents in the early post heart transplant period, leading to improved management and care.